The Weekly Edit – Who Shot it better?

- - The Daily Edit

 

-4

Men’s Fitness

Consulting Design Director: Joseph Heroun
Creative Director: Andy Turnbull
Photo Director: Jane Seymour
Associate Photo Editor: Henry Watson
Photographer: Peter Yang

 

-6

Men’s Health ( US )

Creative Director: Robert Festino
Director of Photography: Jeanne Graves
Art Director: Thomas O’Quinn
Deputy Director of Photography: Don Kinsella
Photo Editor: Mark Haddad
Photographer: Sam Jones

 

 

-5

Men’s Health ( UK )

Creative Director: Declan Fahy
Photo Director: Cat Costelloe
Art Director: Jamie Sage
Deputy Art Director: Marianne Waller
Picture Editor: Alexandra Kelly
Photographer: Patrik Giardino

 

Heidi Volpe

There Are 7 Comments On This Article.

  1. Scott Rex Ely

    Ok, this comparison works for me.
    Peter Yang, doing his best Albert Watson on white. Love it.

  2. Really? All the other work that can be focused on, and these three white studio background w/clutter designs is what we get…?

    Ridiculous

  3. From this months issue of MAGAZINE’S HEALTH:

    10 TIPS TO DE-CLUTTER YOUR COVER

    READ YOUR READER’S SIGNALS: HOW TO REALLY TURN THEM ON

    PLUS ! SHARPEN YOUR WIT WHILE NOT ALIENATING THE ADVERTISERS THAT REMAIN

  4. Gotta give this one to Men’s Heath (USA).
    Although I love the action shot of Men’s Health (UK),
    the lack of second leg makes me wonder if there is a
    story about an MMA fighter that’s an amputee. And
    I really would have like to have seen a mouth in that
    shot as well.

    Men’s Fitness would be second. Kudos to their mast head
    designer for the way they incorporated the apostrophe into
    the text. Should have lost the shirt. If your gonna sell 7% body
    fat, let’s see what it looks like.

  5. Men’s Fitness and not because I love Peter Yang and Norman Reedus immensely, I swear. The photography feels gritty and slick at the same time. But from the subject matter, the UK magazine draws me in more because I want to know his story.